Efficacy of uniportal video-assisted medical thoracoscopy in the management of multiloculated pleural infections: a retrospective study

Abstract

Background

Pleural infection is a serious medical issue for which the appropriate management is still controversial. Complicated (multiloculated) pleural infection usually requires invasive approach.

Results

A retrospective study that aims to assess the efficacy of uniportal video-assisted medical thoracoscopy in the management of complicated (multiloculated) pleural infections. Review of the charts of 37 patients with multiloculated pleural infections who were treated by uniportal video-assisted medical thoracoscopy. There were 30 (81.08%) males and 7 (18.91%) females, age ranging from 22 to 73 years, with a mean age of 49.13 ± 15. Etiology of empyema was complicated parapneumonic effusion in 25 patients (67.5%), tuberculosis in 10 patients (27.02%), and malignancy in 2 patients (5.40%). Treatment of multiloculated pleural infections by uniportal video-assisted medical thoracoscopy was successful in 33 patients (89.1%); those patients did not require any further intervention. Among successful cases, 25 patients (75.75%) showed complete resolution, and 8 patients (24.24%) showed partial success. Four patients (10.81%) required subsequent thoracotomy with decortication.

Conclusion

The conclusion of the present study is that uniportal video-assisted medical thoracoscopy is a safe, valuable, and effective tool in the management of multiloculated pleural infections.

Background

Pleural infection is a serious clinical problem that is associated with significant morbidity and variable mortality ranging from 2 to 30% [1]. Two main categories of pleural infections are recognized which are simple and complex or multiloculated [1].

Different etiologies may lead to the development of pleural infections; it can be either primary caused by pleuropulmonary inflammation or secondary to other causes, like postoperative complications, thoracic trauma, or extension of an inflammatory process in the neck or abdomen [2].

Management of pleural infection includes mainly drainage of the pus from the pleural cavity and treatment of the infection with antimicrobial agents [3].

Drainage procedures range from semi-invasive techniques such as therapeutic aspiration, tube thoracostomy, and intrapleural fibrinolytics to invasive interventions such as thoracoscopy, thoracotomy, or open drainage [4].

Complex or multiloculated pleural infection is a category that often requires invasive interventions; however, the best approach and the time of intervention are still debatable [5].

Medical thoracoscopy is nowadays an important diagnostic and therapeutic tool for pulmonologists. Management of pleural infection is considered one of the non-routine and complex indications of this procedure, and should be certainly performed by highly trained thoracoscopists [6, 7].

Methods

This retrospective study was conducted in the Department of Pulmonary Medicine, Ain Shams University Hospitals, during a 4-year period (March 2012–March 2016).

Inclusion criteria

Review of the files of patients referred to our department with multiloculated pleural infection and treated with medical thoracoscopy.

Pleural infection was defined as frank pus detected on pleural tapping, with or without positive gram stain or bacteriological cultures.

All patients underwent chest radiograph, computed tomography of the chest, and chest ultrasonography.

All patients received empirical antibiotic regimen covering most of the probable germs that was modified later on according to the bacteriological results. Patient with tuberculosis received anti-tuberculous treatment.

The decision to use medical thoracoscopy was made after failure of conservative treatment with antibiotics and pleural aspiration.

Multiloculated pleural infection was identified by the presence of intrapleural septae with multiple loculations, and chest ultrasonography was the radiological method used to identify those cases.

Exclusion criteria

Patients with simple pleural infection (no multiple loculations detected by chest ultrasonography or organized empyema with fibrous thickening of the pleura detected by radiographic techniques) [8]. Patients with no follow up records for at least 6 months after hospital discharge were also excluded.

Thoracoscopy procedure

In all patients, fasting for at least 6 h is required with no other special preoperative preparation. The patients are monitored before and during the whole procedure (blood pressure, pulse, ECG, and pulse oximetry); the procedure was performed in lateral decubitus position with the affected side upward under general analgesia using a combination of inhalation anesthetic (isoflurane) and intravenous anesthetic (propofol).

Skin sterilization was performed followed by incision and blunt dissection in the appropriate intercostal space to access the pleural space; the choice for the site of entry was guided by chest ultrasonography performed on table in the lateral decubitus position. A 10-mm trocar was then inserted, and a 0° telescope was inserted through it and connected to a video camera; the pleural space was carefully inspected through the thoracoscope (TEKNO, Germany).

Fibrinous septae and adhesions were perforated, divided, and aspirated; forceps was used to remove debris (Figs. 1 and 2). At the end of the procedure, a chest drain (28F) was inserted and connected to underwater seal. IV antibiotics were given to all patients for at least 5 days following the procedure.

Fig. 1

Biopsy forceps used to cut intrapleural adhesions

Fig. 2

Encysted empyema with adhesions between visceral and parietal pleura

Successful treatment was defined by radiological improvement, that is consistent after month following chest tube removal, in the form of complete or partial resolution (reduction of the size of the pleural opacity to less than one third of the pleural space), with no need for further interventions or chest tube insertion, and evidence of clinical and laboratory improvements (improvements in body temperature, clinical picture, and inflammatory markers). Follow-up records were available for 6 months after hospital discharge, so patients who required any kind of later interventions were identified.

Statistical analysis

Quantitative data were represented as mean (±SD), and qualitative data were represented as number and percentage. Data entry and statistical analysis were performed using (SPSS for Windows, version 20.0; SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA).

Results

This retrospective study included 37 patients with multiloculated pleural infection, 30 (81.08%) patients were males, and 7 (18.91%) were females. Age of the included patients ranged from 22 to 73 years, with a mean age of 49.13 ± 15.

The etiology of empyema was complicated parapneumonic effusion in 25 patients (67.5%), tuberculosis in 10 patients (27.02%), and malignancy in 2 patients (5.40%) which is proved to be pleural mesothelioma (Table 1). Microbiological culture results revealed no detected germs in most of the patients (Table 2).

Table 1 Sociodemographic data and etiology of pleural infection in the studied patients (n = 37)

Table 2 Microbiological diagnosis of pleural fluid in studied patients (n = 37)

Uniportal video-assisted medical thoracoscopy was performed to all patients, ultrasound guidance to identify the best port of entry was applied in all cases.

The length of the procedure ranged from 45 to 72 min, with a mean length of 53 ± 11.6.

Chest drain was inserted at the end of the procedure, and the duration of drainage ranged from 7 to 12 days with a mean duration of 8.83 ± 1.66.

Treatment of multiloculated pleural infection by medical thoracoscopy was successful in 33 patients (89.1%), and 25 patients (67.5%) showed complete resolution of the pleural fluid on further radiographic assessment performed 1 month after the chest tube removal, and 8 patients (21.6%) showed partial success, and none of the successful cases required any further surgical interventions or chest tube insertion in the follow-up period (Table 3). Four patients (10.81%) required subsequent thoracotomy with decortication due to persistent sizable empyema (Table 3).

Table 3 Outcome of multiloculated pleural infection after treatment with medical thoracoscopy in the studied patients (N = 37)

No recorded mortality, and complications related to the procedure occurred in 3 patients (8.10%), 2 patients developed prolonged air leak for 4 to 6 days, and 1 patient had subcutaneous emphysema.

All complications were spontaneously resolved and did not affect the final outcome.

Discussion

The role of medical thoracoscopy in the management of pleural infection is gaining more and more interests, and it is able to efficiently breakdown adhesions and septations, and to remove fibrin debris from the pleural cavity. It is considered less invasive than other surgical procedures [9].

This retrospective study reviewed the charts of 37 patients with multiloculated pleural infection, for whom uniportal video-assisted medical thoracoscopy was performed in order to manage their condition; all our patients had their procedure done under guidance of chest ultrasonography, which is proved to better identify the best point of entry, lowers the risk of complications, and shortens the length of the procedure [10].

The etiology of pleural infection in most of the patients in this series was complicated parapneumonic effusion (67.5%), and other etiologies included tuberculosis (27.02%), and pleural mesothelioma (5.40%).

Apart from the 10 cases (27.02%) who were diagnosed with tuberculosis, the microbiological profile of the studied patients revealed gram-positive germs in 2 cases (5.4%), gram-negative germs in 3 cases (8.1%), anaerobic organisms in one patient (2.7%), mixed germs in 2 cases (5.4%), while no germs have been detected in culture and sensitivity in most of the patients (51.35%). These low-yield results for cultures are mostly due to antibiotics used by those patients prior to sampling, and it was demonstrated in a previous study [11].

It was previously recommended in the literature to use medical thoracoscopy early in the course of empyema [12]. This present retrospective study was mainly focused on multiloculated pleural infection, and it showed that uniportal video-assisted medical thoracoscopy was successful in the management of 33 out of 37 patients (89.1%). Among those patients, 75.75% showed complete resolution of the pleural fluid, and 24.4% showed partial resolution with residual pleural thickening. None of them required any further surgical interventions.

Our results are in accordance with previous studies, and Ravaglia et al. [13] have demonstrated successful management of multiloculated pleural infection using medical thoracoscopy in 91.7%. Another study [14] reported successful treatment in 91% of the cases of multiloculated pleural infection with medical thoracoscopy, but they stated 49% of the patients received post interventional intrapleural fibrinolytics, which was not applied in any of our patients.

There was no recorded mortality. Complications were minimal, and it occurred in only 3 patients (8.10%) and was resolved spontaneously. This agrees with the fact that medical thoracoscopy is a safe procedure, and other studies have confirmed the occurrence of minimal complications in the management of multiloculated pleural infection with medical thoracoscopy [13, 14].

Conclusion

The conclusion of the present study is that uniportal video-assisted medical thoracoscopy is a safe, valuable, and effective tool in the management of multiloculated pleural infection.